« Things Fall Apart, Or, A Crazy Motherfucker Named Ice Cube | Main | Iraq »

March 10, 2006

Reviewing the Reviewer, or, Smelling the Armpits of Lester Bangs & Realising I Don't Mind the Smell

bangs1.jpg

I must admit I had sat down at this here kitchen table with the intention of saying the unspeakable: that rock critic Lester Bangs just wasn’t that good. And I must also confess this: that I had impure motives, o lord!, that the casual dismissal of received wisdom gladdened me, but I can see clearly now…

I had picked up Bangs’ anthology Psychotic Reactions and Carburetor Dung: The Work of a Legendary Critic last Christmas—an exquisite example of selfishness—and would thumb casually through it when the weight of Gore Vidal got too heavy. Last night the weight of Gore Vidal got too heavy, and so I read a number of articles which, in turn, exasperated, illuminated, excited and bored me.

For one, Bangs’ Mailer-machismo got to me. Page after page of that hum-buzz-spittle-spat! language of the larger-than-life pop-intellectual-hedonist cramming aphorism and life-force into as small a space as possible. Mailer tried to do it all the time—grandiose insights (inspired by the Greeks, tempered by Muhammad Ali’s lefts and rights) weren’t enough of a show for him; Mailer wanted to concentrate these wisdoms, aphorise them; make them the literary equivalent of a black-hole—dense and throbbing illuminations of a unique intellect:

Henry Miller, however, exists in the same relation to legend that anti-matter shows to matter.

Mailer often failed, but it was fun to watch him try.

Hemingway was the best in showing so much in so little, and before he began plagiarising himself, he gave us some of the best sentences of the last century:

His talent was as natural as the pattern that was made by the dust on a butterfly’s wings. At one time he understood it no more than the butterfly did and he did not know when it was brushed or marred. Later he became conscious of his damaged wings and of their construction and he learned to think and could no longer fly any more because the love of flight was gone and he could only remember when it had been effortless.

Bangs was not Hemingway, and didn’t want to be. He was too impatient. He shares the energy and snarl and machismo of Mailer, and his exhaustive, manic search for the vague, ugly-beautiful life-force, performed, or divined, by the best rock bands:

Look at it this way: there are many here among us for whom the life force is best represented by the livid twitching of one tortured nerve, or even a full-scale anxiety attack. I do not subscribe to this 100%, but I understand it, have lived it. Thus the shriek, the caterwaul, the chainsaw gnarlgnashing, the yowl and the whiz that decapitates may be reheard by the adventurous or emotionally damaged as mellifluous bursts of unarguable affirmation.

But perhaps more so, Bangs shared similarities with Hunter S. Thompson. Bangs’ rambling, ranting, invective-ridden prose (often coloured by drugs) resembled Thompson’s gonzo exercises, and they both shared a cultivated iconoclasm, confident in their writing, their drugs, their drink, their Search….

I must say that I tired of Bangs’ style—all spit and scream and cavernous, delirious insight. I also tired of Lou Reed featuring in every second fucking article, and (like Thompson) the continual self-reference and the drugs and the drugs and the drugs… but then I would come across something like this:

You always wonder how you will react to these things, but I can’t say that I was surprised when NBC broke into the “Tonight Show” to say that John Lennon was dead. I always thought that he would be the first of the Beatles to die, because he was always the one who lived the most on the existential edge, whether by diving knees-first into left-wing adventurism or by just shutting up for five years when he decided he really didn’t have anything much to say; but I had always figured it would be by his own hand. That he was merely the latest celebrity to be gunned down by a probable psychotic only underscores the banality surrounding his death.
Look: I don’t think I’m insensitive or a curmudgeon. In 1965 John Lennon was one of the most important people in the world. It’s just that today I feel deeply alienated from rock ‘n’ roll and what it has meant or could mean, alienated from my fellow men and women and their dreams and aspirations.

Clear and quick like a cool stream, and smart to boot. When I discovered Bangs’ review of Van Morrison’s Astral Weeks any thought that Bangs was a gibbering anarchist with no heart and amphetamine-charged antennae shifted: Bangs’ was a talented, gibbering anarchist, with a great heart and amphetamine-charged antennae:

Van Morrison’s Astral Weeks was released ten years, almost to the day, before this was written. It was particularly important to me because the fall of 1968 was such a terrible time: I was a physical and mental wreck, nerves shredded and ghosts and spiders looming and squatting across the mind. My social contacts had dwindled to almost none; the presence of other people made me nervous and paranoid. I spent endless days and nights sunk in an armchair in my bedroom, reading magazines, watching TV, listening to records, staring into space. I had no idea how to improve the situation and probably wouldn’t have done anything about it if I had.
Astral Weeks would be the subject of this piece—i.e., the rock record with the most significance in my life so far—no matter how I’d been feeling when it came out. But in the condition I was in, it assumed at the time the quality of a beacon, a light on the far shores of the murk; what’s more, it was proof that there was something left to express artistically besides nihilism and destruction.

Here Bangs is at his best—it sounds like he’s breathing. He’s also reassuringly instructive: “…it was proof that there was something left to express artistically besides nihilism and destruction”.

Bangs was a guy that wrote rock reviews. He was talented, intelligent, and when the ego and the drugs and the spleen didn’t crack the fabric, he was a superb writer. His machismo and obsession with Lou annoys me, sure, but the antennae never stopped searching—I can see him swaggering around the streets of Detroit with his earphones blaring (Metal Machine Music), taking it all in: the dirt, the hypocrisy, the shadow, but also, when he was very, very good, the light.

Posted by Marty at March 10, 2006 12:46 PM

Comments

The best, angriest, maybe funniest, certainly drunkest thing ever written about rock writing: Bangs' How to be a Rock Critic: A Megatonic Journey. Those Pitchfork kids oughta read it... Except that delightful Nick Sylvester, who's so. fucking. fired.

Seymour Hoffman did a great Bangs in almost famous. Probably his first really great performance.

Posted by: patrick at March 10, 2006 3:17 PM